data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5ebdb/5ebdb9d2d4884ee72e53e8da1cab9cc165411bf7" alt=""
Stewardship
Each of you must give as you have made up your mind, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver. - 2 Corinthians 9:7
CHOOSE LIFE!
A man in New York City was riding the subway to work on his sixtieth birthday. The train was crowded and he was standing in the aisle holding onto one of the straps. He was reflecting on this milestone in his life, what had come before and what might lie ahead, when he noticed that sitting right next to where he stood was a very attractive young woman. As he looked down at her, she looked up, their eyes met, and she gave him a big smile. He thought to himself, “Well, buddy, you haven’t lost it yet. Sixty years old and you’ve still got what it takes.” Then the young woman smiled again, and she said, “Can I give you my seat?”
This story connects with us on many levels. Most deeply, it connects with our yearning for life – our innate yearning not just for brain wave and pulsebeat life, but for vitality, energy, strength, joy, fulfillment, meaning. That yearning is the context in which the Bible presents us with a choice: growing tree or dead stump.
These images were even more fraught in biblical times than they are today. Back then, trees weren’t just part of a pretty landscape. What came to people’s minds first were fruit-bearing trees – olive trees or fig trees – on which they depended for food and income. Whether the fig or olive harvest was good or bad could spell the difference between prosperity and poverty. So the picture of a dead stump represented not only desolation, but also disaster.
So we hear Proverbs 11:28: “A God-shaped life is a growing tree; a life devoted to things is a dead stump.”1 Today we’re going to look at three characteristics of a God-shaped life. As we do, we won’t be able to avoid noticing that these characteristics are direct opposites of a life devoted to things.
First, a God-shaped life is characterized by contentment. Contentment is the ability to rest secure and peaceful in what we have, knowing that it comes to us as a gift from God. In the last chapter of his first letter to Timothy, Paul speaks out against the sleazy televangelists of his day, accusing them of seeing godliness as a get-rich-quick scheme, a means of financial gain. Then he stops and clarifies, “Of course, there is great gain in godliness combined with contentment; for we brought nothing into the world, and so we can take nothing out of it; but if we have food and clothing, we will be content with these” (1 Timothy 6:6-7).
This sounds almost quaint, being content with food and clothing. Really, who lives like that anymore? Yet contentment characterizes the God-shaped life.
A wise person once said, “No one ever cured an itch by getting really good at scratching.” We have this restless, relentless itch—that desire for just a little bit more. We scratch by getting a little bit more. But then we find that we still want just a little bit more. Scratching, as always, just makes things worse. The only cure for our itch is contentment.
Michael Norton teaches at Harvard Business School. In the September 13, 2010, issues of Forbes magazine, he writes, “Does money buy happiness? We certainly behave as though it does, spending most of our waking hours pursuing it. If only we got that raise, owned that second home, third car or 3G iPad, things would be better, we tell ourselves. We would finally be happy.”2
Then he continues, “Truth be told, people drastically overestimate the impact of changes in income on their wellbeing.” And he cites a survey that he and some colleagues conducted. The survey revealed that, once basic needs are met, more income does little or nothing to increase our happiness. (All of a sudden, being content with food and clothing doesn’t seem so quaint.) Michael Norton concludes, “Money certainly makes some things in life easier, but many aspects of life remain irritatingly the same. You might make more money, but you’re still stuck with the same in-laws, siblings, traffic jams, and software glitches.” So our pursuit of more stuff and money sounds more and more like Paul’s warning that the desire to be rich may plunge us into “many senseless desires” (1 Timothy 6:9).
When Cynthia Campbell was President of McCormick Theological Seminary in Chicago, she spoke of a man from whom she learned her valuable life lessons. He was an attendant at the parking garage where she left her car after driving to work. His white hair, lined face, and hesitating step made it pretty clear that he was well past what most of us would think of as retirement age. It did’t take much guesswork to surmise that he was showing up every day not because of the sheer delight of being a parking garage attendant, but rather out of stark economic necessity. Yet when she drove in each day he greeted her with a smile, and when she said, “Good morning, how are you?” he invariably responded, “I’m blessed.”3
I’m blessed. He could have been preoccupied with all the things he did’t have, all the ways his life wasn’t what it should have been. But he chose contentment. He decided to experience life as saturated with God’s gifts. And so can we.
Let’s take a moment to try to get a grip on the interplay between compassion and our attitude toward money and possessions. I grew up near Long Island Sound, and one day when I was a teenager, I got drafted, not unwillingly, to be part of the crew on a brand-new forty-foot sailboat owned by friends of my parents. A few hours into our sail, with the wind growing stronger and stronger, we were tacking into the wind. The boat was heeling way over, with the lee rail awash with a torrent of water. That’s when the owner, seated at the wheel, sent me forward along that lee rail to trim one of the sails. He handed me a winch handle and told me what to do. So there I was, going forward, knee deep in water, having one of those classic conversations with myself. Part of me was saying, “How cool is this?” while another part of me was saying, “I’m going to slip overboard!” That’s when I heard the owner calling out from behind the wheel. “Be careful!” he shouted. “That winch handle cost $200!” He was doing the math. He was keenly focused on the pricy winch handle; on the kid holding the winch handle, not so much.
Friends, our preoccupation with money and possessions drains away our compassion. Our worry about money and possessions drains away our compassion. The conviction that we’re just one promotion or one new purchase away from real happiness keeps us from seeing the humanity of the people around us and blinds us to their needs.
With a God-shaped life, we will care genuinely and about our neighbor, a coworker, the cashier at Costco. But our compassion will go beyond that. The God-shaped life is content with what we have, but the God-shaped life is not content with the way the world is. Compassion includes a holy discontent with poverty, inequality, oppression, and war. When we are compassionate, our hearts beat and break with the heart of God.
The third characteristic of a God-shaped life is generosity. Compassion without generosity is mere emotional froth. Authentic compassion always issues in meaningful generosity. The most famous verse in the New Testament is John 3:16: “For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.” God’s love always involves giving.
I’m so glad the Bible doesn’t say, “God so loved the world that he felt a twinge of sorrow for human beings before he changed the channel.” I’m so glad the Bible doesn’t say, “God so loved the world that he said, ‘That’s terrible, but I just can’t afford to help.’” No, the Bible says, “God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son.”
That act of giving teaches us much about genuine generosity. God’s gift of his Son was no whim; rather, it was planned from eternity past. Over the centuries of human history, God worked his plan through Abraham, the nation of Israel, the prophets, and others, until Jesus came to earth. And the plan issued in a gift that was a tremendous sacrifice – the death of God’s Son on the cross. Thus God-shaped generosity, on our part, will also be planned and sacrificial. It’s easy to congratulate ourselves on our generosity when we buy a box of Girl Scout cookies or give a few dollars to the neighbor engaging in a walk for charity. Now don’t get me wrong – this is a good thing and we need to keep doing it with enthusiasm and joy. But God-shaped generosity goes beyond this. It’s giving we have to plan for and discipline ourselves to. And God-shaped giving will truly represent a sacrifice.
So we see three characteristics of the God-shaped life, and we recognize that they are very different, even mutually exclusive, from the life devoted to things.
“A God-shaped life is a growing tree; a life devoted to things is a dead stump.”
You choose.
DOGS, CATS, AND THE JOY ATTITUDE
I’ll start with words often attributed to George Carlin, who is not one of my usual go-to theological sources. Whoever wrote these words, they look penetratingly at our lives today.
The paradox of our time in history is that we have taller buildings, but shorter tempers, wider freeways but narrower viewpoints.
We spend more, but have less; we buy more, but enjoy less.
We have more conveniences but less time, more degrees but less sense, more knowledge but less judgment, more experts yet more problems, more medicine but less wellness.
We drink too much, smoke too much, spend too recklessly, laugh too little, drive too fast, get too angry, stay up too late, get u p too tired, read too little, and pray too seldom.
We have multiplied our possessions, but reduced our values.
We’ve learned how to make a living, but not a life.
We’ve added years to life, not life to years.
We’ve learned to rush, but not to wait.
These are times of steep profits and shallow relationships, times when there is much in the showroom window and nothing in the stockroom.
In the midst of all this, we hear the voice of Jesus, perhaps faintly at first, but more and more clearly if we will listen. We hear the voice of Jesus assuring us that he came so that his joy might be in us and our joy might be complete (John 15:11). His joy in us, our joy complete. Could anything be more different from what this paradoxical world of ours has to offer? Yet it is not just wishful thinking; it is Jesus’ purpose and Jesus’ promise to us. So this morning we’ll explore how we can more deeply experience the joy of Jesus.
Which brings us to the difference between dogs and cats. In case you’ve forgotten, let me remind you.
A dog looks at you and thinks, “You put food in my food bowl and water in my water dish. You take me on walks around the neighborhood. You tickle my tummy in just the right way. You must be God.”
A cat looks at you and thinks, “You put food in my food bowl and water in my water dish. You change the kitty litter in my dirt box. You scratch behind my ears in just the right way. I must be God.”
There is cat spirituality and dog spirituality. Cat spirituality says, “Look at all these blessings. I have acquired them by my effort and skill. I must be God.” Dog spirituality thinks, “Look at all these blessings. They come to be ultimately as a gift. You must be God.”
We see cat spirituality on display in Jesus’ parable from Luke 12. The wealthy farmer’s land produces an extraordinary crop, more than anyone could have imagined. The barns are too small to hold it all. So he says, “Build bigger barns!” When these big barns are crammed full, the wealthy farmer thinks to himself, “I have secured my future for years to come. I must be God.” There’s only one teensy-weensy little problem: He’s not God, and that very night he dies. How might his life have been different, how might his choices have been different, if he lived with the perspective, “You must be God”?
For centuries, perhaps millennia, the debate has raged over whether cats or dogs are better. I am not expressing any opinion about that (which is good, because if I did one half or the other of the congregation would hate me!). But I can tell you this with absolute certainty: Dog spirituality is more accurate, more life-giving, more joy-producing.
Joy comes as we recognize and celebrate our dependence on God. Joy comes as we recognize and celebrate the faithfulness of the God on home we depend. And the most basic way we do this is through gratitude. Gratitude is an indispensable component of joy. It is impossible to be joyful without being grateful. If we want to grow our joy, we will cultivate gratitude.
Let me briefly share three action steps for cultivating gratitude.
First, slow down and pay attention. We race through our days at such a breakneck pace that we are scarcely aware of God’s blessings, let alone giving thanks for them. This is cat spirituality. In her book An Altar in the World, Barbara Brown Taylor writes:
The practice of paying attention really does take time. Most of us move so quickly that our surroundings become no more than blurred scenery we fly past on our way to somewhere else. We pay attention to the speedometer, the wristwatch, the cell phone, the list of things to do … These devices sustain the illusion that we might yet be gods – if only we could find some way to do more faster.4
Gratitude and hurry don’t mix well. Train yourself pause and admire the shape of a leaf and its roadmap of veins, to be amazed by the architecture of a flower, to rejoice in the pastel hues of a subtle sunset. Stop moving long enough to revel in the laughter of a child, notice a spouse who’s just washed the dishes, sense the gentle word or touch of a friend that says, “We’re in this together.” Slow down and pay attention.
Second, count your blessings. This sounds old-fashioned, but it’s essential. Take a few minutes before going to bed to review the day, taking note of God’s gifts to you during it, and thank God for them. When I’m attending to my spiritual life as I should, every few days I put pen to paper and make a list of the blessings I’ve been receiving from God. Reflecting like this puts my life in perspective and stirs thankfulness in my heart.
You may want to counter, “What about those awful days when there are no blessings. This leads me to remember a man I used to know. Whenever some would say to him, “It’s good to see you,” he would respond, “It’s better to be seen than to be viewed.” Even the most difficult days come to us as gifts from God, and God will be with us as we face each challenge.
In addition to having a regular practice of counting our blessings, sometimes we need to count our blessings on the fly. Over the years, I’ve hear people grump about the common Christmas time experience of having to park miles away from the store and then walking past a dozen or more empty handicapped parking places right by the door. I once saw a bumper sticker that addressed these complaints. It was on a car in the very first handicapped space, and it read, “I’d rather have your legs than my parking place.” So, as you’re walking into a store past vacant parking places, do a quick count of your blessings. And if you’re beginning to gripe that you’re not driving a better car into a better parking space at a better store where you could afford to buy better things, stop and thank God that you at least have a car to park, money to buy some necessities, and legs to walk into the store. And gratitude will produce joy that dispels your resentment.
Third, increase your generosity. Genuine gratitude is always evidenced by generosity. Unless it finds expression in liberal and cheerful giving, gratitude becomes desiccated, lifeless. Gratitude without generosity is mere theory; it has yet to lay hold of our hearts.
Clutching our stuff more tightly is cat spirituality. “I got this stuff by my intelligence and my hard work, and I’ve got to protect it, because if there’s going to be any providing, any blessing, any security, it’s because I make it happen. I must be God!” But with dog spirituality, we see life crammed with God’s blessings and ourselves as the recipients of gifts beyond number. We’re freed from fear and therefore free to give.
The two kinds of spirituality ask very different questions when considering generosity. Cat spirituality asks, “How much of my money should I give?” Dog spirituality asks, “How much of God’s money does God want me to give?”
The Bible says, “Give thanks in all circumstances, for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus for you” (1 Thessalonians 5:18). This isn’t God insisting on politeness—“Now children, what do you say?” No, this is God’s invitation to experience what it’s like for Jesus’ joy to be in us and our joy to be complete. If we want to grow our joy, we will cultivate gratitude.
POSSESSED
I once heard John Ortberg tell a story of his family’s adventures with furniture. When John and his wife, Nancy, were first married, they had no money to speak of. Everything they owned was castoff or garage sale. In their little living room they had a brown couch. It was old, worn, faded and tattered. You could do anything on the brown couch – sit on it, play on it, sleep on it, eat on it. They didn’t care. When John got home from work, he would put the kids on the brown couch and bounce them up and down on it, saying, “Yayayayaya!” It became known as the yaya couch.”
In time, John and Nancy saved some money, and they went to the store and bought their first piece of nice furniture. It was a sofa the color of Pepto-Bismol. (This was the 1980s.) The salesman called it mauve, however, and the Ortbergs proudly brought it home.
Anybody want to guess what the number one rule was? That’s right: Don’t sit on the mauve sofa. And another thing: don’t play on the mauve sofa, don’t eat on the mauve sofa, don’t look at the mauve sofa, don’t think about the mauve sofa. On every other piece of furniture in the house, thou mayest freely sit. But upon the mauve sofa, thou shalt not sit. For on the day thou sittest upon the mauve sofa, thou shalt surely die.
Then one day there appeared on the mauve sofa a stain, a red stain, a red jelly stain. Nancy assembled the three children in front of the mauve sofa – they’re ages four, two-and-a-half, and six months. And Nancy said, “Children, that is a stain, a red stain, a red jelly stain. And the man at the sofa store says it’s not coming out, not ever, not for all eternity. Do you know how long eternity is, children? It’s how long you’re going to sit here until someone tells me who put the red jelly stain on the mauve sofa.” They just sat there, silent, because they knew something horrible would happen to whoever did it.
By the time I heard the story, many years had passed since then. Both the mauve sofa and the yaya couch were long gone from the Ortberg household. And these were John’s words as he looked back:
“All my good memories are about the yaya couch. To this day I can close my eyes and see myself coming home from work, throwing those little bodies on the couch, watching them bounce up and down, and listening to all those giggles. But my only good memory of the mauve sofa is the day I sat on it alone eating a jelly doughnut.”1
It’s a funny thing, isn’t it? We call them our possessions, but too often they end up possessing us. Our stuff and our money tend to assume control over us, commanding our time and energy, our attention and deference.
In the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus tries to make us aware of the spiritual reality behind the phenomenon of our possessions possessing us. He makes this pointed statement: “No one can serve two masters … You cannot serve both God and wealth.” The word translated wealth is actually a peculiar Aramaic word, mammon. It means money and the things money can buy. The noun mammon comes from the Aramaic verb “to trust,” connoting that in which one trusts – a very suggestive way to refer to wealth, wouldn’t you agree? It’s noteworthy that Matthew doesn’t use a Greek synonym for mammon, but simply spells it out phonetically in the Greek alphabet. By implication: Pay attention, this is the exact word Jesus used, and it matters!
So let’s stop and think: Could it be that Jesus is treating money and possessions as more than just things? After all, he gives them a name – mammon. And he makes clear that mammon is a master, mammon is a false god seeking to rule our lives.
There’s a sense in which mammon, as a rival god, isn’t neutral, waiting to be used positively or negatively according to our attitudes and choices. Mammon, Jesus implies, is an active power seeking to secure our loyalty and commitment, to be the center of our attention.
This spiritual reality comes out plainly in one scene from the movie, “Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps,” In the movie, Michael Douglas portrays Gordon Gekko, once a big money guy, a corporate raider, who served eight years in prison for his financial misdeeds but now is out and on the rebound. He meets Jacob Moore, an ambitious young proprietary trader, and they talk on the subway:
Jacob says, “I’m in this game to make money, just like anyone else.”
“So what about money, Jake?” Gordon replies. “Do you like her?”
Jacob is taken aback: “I’ve never thought about money as a she.”
Gordon Gekko shakes his head and smiles. “Oh, she lies there in bed at night with you, looking at you, one eye open. Money never sleeps, and she’s jealous, and if you don’t pay close, close attention, you wake up in the morning and she might be gone forever.”
Here too we find money depicted, not as something inert, but as demanding our devotion.
Richard Foster, in his bestselling book, “The Challenge of the Disciplined Life,” writes,
“Money is not just an impersonal medium of exchange. Mammon is … an active agent; it is a law unto itself; and it is capable of inspiring devotion. … It is the spiritual reality behind money that we want so badly to deny. For years I felt that Jesus was exaggerating by fixing such a huge gulf between mammon and God. … But the thing I failed to see, and the thing that Jesus saw so clearly, is the way in which mammon makes a bid for our hearts.”2
The Sermon on the Mount is a call to action, a summons to dethrone mammon and serve only God. Yet I have this fear. I fear that we American Christians hear Jesus say, “You cannot serve both God and mammon,” and we think to ourselves, “I bet we can. Let’s try. We’re the exception.” We’d never actually say that, of course, but our behavior demonstrates that we believe it. And we end up serving our stuff, often doubly enslaved because we’re in denial about our bondage.
How then can we break free of the master mammon so that we can serve God? Here are two practical steps:
First, reprogram your thinking. Every significant change begins with a new way of thinking. We’ve already begun rethinking by acknowledging that mammon is a master vying for our commitment. In addition, we need to recognize that mammon is not a god worthy of our commitment. Only God is eternal, only God is always faithful, and so only God can be our rock and our fortress. Mammon doesn’t last, and we’re certainly not taking it with us when we leave this life. So we need to find ways to keep reminding ourselves that money and possessions are temporary and fleeting.
I’m reminded of a family that moved from the New York City suburbs to a farm in New Hampshire in an attempt to simplify their lives. They bought two calves that they planned to raise for beef. But the parents were afraid that the children, who had only had pets before this, would get attached to the animals and be devastated when it was time to have them slaughtered. So the parents came up with a way to help the children never forget that the calves would be with them only briefly. They gave them strategic names. They named them Freezer #1 and Freezer #2.
Maybe you should name your car Junkyard or nickname your brand-new clothes Ragbag. That is their destiny! Whatever method you choose, do something to keep reminding yourself that stuff doesn’t last, we can’t rely on it.
Beyond this, never forget that even in the short term mammon can’t deliver on the promises it makes to satisfy and fulfill us. That’s why we constantly need more. By contrast, “God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes on him shall not perish but have everlasting life” (John 3:16). Does mammon really love you, really give you life?
In the face of the daily tidal wave of messages telling us we need more, let’s find practical ways to stay grounded in reality. For instance, Chuck Swindoll writes,
I recall hearing some pretty good counsel on how to overrule those commercials that attempt to convince us we need this product or that new appliance to be happy. The guy suggested that every time we begin to feel that tug, we shout back at the tube at the top of our voices: “WHO ARE YOU KIDDING!”
It really works. My whole family and I tried it one afternoon during a televised football game. Not once did I feel dissatisfied with my present lot. Our dog almost had a canine coronary. But other than that, the results were great.3
You may not choose this strategy, but find something that helps you reprogram your thinking.
Second, recalibrate your giving. Generous giving declares our independence of mammon. Every act of joyful and generous giving breaks a link in the chain keeping us in bondage to that false god.
This is a primary reason why I believe so strongly in the biblical practice of tithing. The Bible directs us to tithe – to give 10% of our income to the Lord – for our benefit. It’s not an ancient fundraising strategy; it’s to protect our spiritual health. I’ve grown convinced that ten percent is the minimum it takes to break free from mammon. Ten percent is the baseline for turning from devotion to things to serving the true and living God. When we give less than that, it’s likely we’re trying to serve two masters.
You have the opportunity to take this liberating step when you make your pledge to God’s work at Palmetto Presbyterian Church for 2024. Once again, we’re encouraging you not just to look at what you pledged last year and simply decide whether to keep the amount the same or give God a cost-of-living increase. Rather, total up your income and then divide by ten; that’s a tithe. If it is honestly impossible for you to give that amount next year, then develop and implement a plan that will get you to that level of giving soon. A successful plan for many people has been increasing their giving by one percent of their income every year until they reach the point where they are tithing.
When you consider tithing, you may feel a twinge of fear: What if I won’t have enough? One of mammon’s favorite tactics is fear. But when we tithe, we say no to fear, we assert that we will depend on God, not mammon, to supply our needs. And make no mistake, God always comes through.
I had just finished a sermon on tithing at my very first church when an elderly gentleman in the congregation cornered me. “Young man,” he said, “I need to speak with you.” When he saw he had my attention, he continued. “My social security and my little pension do not cover my living expenses.” He paused, and I wondered how insensitive my sermon had been to situations like his. Then he repeated himself for emphasis before going on: “My social security and my little pension do not cover my living expenses. But when I tithe, they do.” This was his testimony. When he put God first, God somehow provided far better than mammon would have.
“No one can serve to masters,” Jesus said. “You cannot serve both God and mammon.” May we reprogram our thinking and recalibrate our giving so that we will no longer be possessed.
TOYS AND TREASURE
A woman went to the pet store to buy a parrot. On the way home she was so excited about having a bird who would talk to her.
A week later, she was back at the pet store.
“My parrot hasn’t said a word,” she complained.
“That’s unusual,” replied the store owner. “Maybe
you should get a ladder. Parrots love ladders. That
should perk him up.”
So she bought a ladder.
A week later she was back.
“My parrot still hasn’t said a word.”
“Maybe you should get a mirror,” the store owner
suggested. “Parrots love mirrors.”
So she bought a mirror.
A week later she was at the store again, and the conversation went like this:
“My parrot died.”
“Oh, no—”
“But before he died, he spoke.”
“Really? What did he say?”
“He said, ‘Don’t they have any food at that pet
store?’”
This sounds a little like our lives. we’re accumulating more and more toys, but we’re starving spiritually. That’s why Jesus, out of sheer love for you and me, talks so much and money and possessions.
In the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus speaks very bluntly. “Do not store up for yourselves treasures on earth,” he begins. A more precise translation would be, “Stop storing up for yourselves treasures on earth.” Jesus knows we are already rushing headlong after earthly treasure. Then he points to the fragility of our stuff, which moth and rust can consume and which thieves can steal. On a deeper level, we are reminded that our money and possessions are incapable of making good on their promise to give our lives meaning and security. Our toys may amuse us, but they can never fulfill us.
Jesus continues, “Store up for yourselves treasures in heaven.” In the Gospels, heaven is not just a future reality. “The kingdom of heaven is near,” Jesus announces, and “Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs in the kingdom of heaven.” Heaven is anyplace where God’s presence and fullest blessings are experienced. One scholar suggests that thinking of storing up “treasures with God” might be helpful.8 So Jesus isn’t just saying that if we do this we’ll be glad when we die. Jesus is making clear that where we store up our treasures will also make a difference in our lives now.
This came through clearly in a study conducted by Christian Smith, a professor of sociology at the University of Notre Dame, reported in his 2014 book, The Paradox of Generosity. The study, which included 2000 Americans, measured five different components of wellbeing and sought to see if there was any link between wellbeing and generosity. Here’s how he summarized his findings: “By giving ourselves away, we ourselves move toward flourishing. This is not only a philosophical or religious teaching: it is a sociological fact.”9 Conversely, the study revealed that when we are not generous, our wellbeing actually decreases. The book’s subtitle is, “Giving we receive, grasping we lose.”
“Stop storing up treasures on earth … Store up treasures in heaven.” When Jesus makaes juxtaposes these two, he is clearly implying that we can’t do both simultaneously. We’d like to figure out how to do both. Jesus says we’re fooling ourselves.
Then Jesus provides this penetrating insight: “Where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.” Treasure never lies. The allocation of our treasure infallibly reveals the location of our hearts. No matter what we claim about our priorities, our treasure tells the truth.
So, if we want to relocate our hearts, we will need to reallocate our treasure. So often I hear people say that they want to get closer to God, to grow spiritually, or to discover God’s purpose for their lives. These yearnings have to do with location of our hearts. I am convinced that many Christians are on the verge of a spiritual breakthrough, except that they won’t release their grip on earthly treasure.
Which brings us to the biblical practice of tithing. Tithing – giving ten percent of our income to God and God’s work in the world – isn’t an ancient fundraising ploy, it’s a crucial pathway to spiritual health and growth. I’m convinced that, for most of us, ten percent is the minimum we’ll need to give in order to slow down our accumulation of earthly treasure and start storing up heavenly treasure, the baseline of giving that will actually start to relocate our hearts.
Next Sunday, we will dedicate our 2024 pledges to the Lord. Let me say a brief word about pledging and our spiritual wellbeing. Sometimes people say to me, “How can I pledge? I don’t know what the coming year will bring. It would be unwise to pre-commit.” The fact is, however, that we pre-commit our finances in many ways: mortgage, car lease or payments, cell phone contract. We pre-commit because these are part of the infrastructure of our lives. What do you think? Would it be spiritually healthy to act as if the infrastructure of our lives includes God?
As you ponder your 2024 pledge, remember a story told about a newlywed couple who had the bride’s family over on their first Christmas as husband and wise. The husband noticed his wife cutting a little off each end of the ham before putting it in the oven. “Why do you do that?” he asked. She answered, “My mother always did.” Well, her mother happened to be in the living room, so he asked her why she sliced a little off each end of the ham before putting it in the oven. “My mother always did,” she said. Well, her mother was sitting on the couch, so he asked her the same question—and received the same reply. Now that young husband was on a mission. He picked up his phone and called his wife’s great-grandmother in her nursing home. “Why did you cut a little off each end of the ham before putting it in the oven?” She answered, “My pan was too short.”
Basing our actions on what we’ve done before makes sense only if we had the right starting point. Many of us, when considering our pledge for next year, will simply decide whether to keep it the same as this year or increase it a little. OK, then why did we decide on the current year’s amount?’ The answer is usually that we based it on the amount we gave the previous year. And why did we give what we gave that year? Well, it was a little more than the year before. And so on. Eventually we find ourselves saying, “I don’t know why I gave that amount.” Yet this has been the basis for years of giving. We’re still slicing off the ends of the ham. So this year I’m encouraging to calculate what a tithe would be for you and use that as the starting point as you pray about your 2024 pledge.
Stop storing up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moth and rust consume and thieves break in and steal. Store up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where moth and rust do not consume and thieves do not break in a steal. For where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.
* * * * * * *
1. This rendering of Proverbs 11:28 is adapted from The Message, Eugene Peterson’s lively paraphrase of the Bible.
2. Forbes, September 13, 2010, p. 18.
3. From a sermon preached by Cynthia Campbell at Fourth Presbyterian Church, Chicago, and distributed by The Presbyterian Foundation.
4. Bargara Brown Taylor, An Altar in the World (San Francisco: HarperOne, 2009), p. 24
5. From a sermon preached at Menlo Park Presbyterian Church and distributed by The Presbyterian Foundation.
6. Richard Foster, The Challenge of the Disciplined Life (HarperSanFrancisco, 1985), p. 26.
7. Charles R. Swindoll, Strengthening Your Grip (Minneapolis: WorldWide, 1978), p. 77.
8. R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2007), p. 258.
9. Christian Smith and Hilary Davidson, The Paradox of Generosity (New York: Oxford University Press, 2014), p. 1.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/86faf/86faf2396db8f195513c22bf660d319cd432a500" alt=""